The Rolodex Spirit in a Digital World

I was sitting on my patio this morning, looking over the week behind me and thinking of the one ahead. While watching the rising sun reflect off the San Jacinto Mountains, I thought back on a post I read earlier this week discussing the "leaky bucket" in modern real estate.

The "leaky bucket" is a metaphor for a staggering statistic: over 50% of online leads never receive a response.

That statistic is the basis for today's reflection. It got me thinking about a piece of equipment that once sat on every desk I ever occupied. It was called the Rolodex.

For the younger generation who may not know, the Rolodex was a rotating wheel of small cards. It was tactile, and it was heavy. That wheel had a weight to it. When you turned it, you could hear the “click-click-click” of your livelihood. I can also share with you that there were times when my Rolodex looked full of blank cards. When that happened, the silence of those empty cards literally scared me into action.

When you used a Rolodex, you didn’t just "scroll"—you hunted.

You hunted through those cards for an excuse to call or drop a note in the mail. You were looking for a reason to check in. More importantly, adding a card wasn't just "data entry." It was a commitment.

Space was limited, so every entry had to earn its spot.

You wrote down everything you could on those little cards: a spouse’s name, an anniversary, a kid’s graduation, birthdays, or even the dog's name. Because you had to physically flip through those cards to find one person, you "visited" your entire network along the way.

Please stick with me. Here's my point:

Today, we have the "Database." We have CRMs—Customer Relationship Management systems.

For my fellow veterans, a CRM is essentially your digital filing cabinet, mailing service, and secretary all rolled into one. It’s designed to track every "touch" so nothing falls through the cracks. It can hold 10,000 names and automate emails based on "click-through rates."

But here is the irony: We’ve become experts at collecting names and novices at building relationships.

We’ve traded the personal touch for a "set-it-and-forget-it" strategy. With all the power of the modern database, many are responding to fewer people than we did when we used the Rolodex and a rotary phone.

A Database is built for Efficiency. But by comaprison, the Rolodex was built for Intimacy.

I’m not suggesting we move backward. I’m suggesting that in a world of high-tech automation, the highest ROI still comes from high-touch relationship management.

Technology—and even the AI I’m using to help me organize my day, these thoughts, and spell check my posts—should be embraced. But it should only be used to clear the "busy work" so you can get back to the personal work. We need to get back to building relationships, not just sending electronic messages. We have to embrace the human element we bring to the business; we can't afford to lose our personalities.

Your database is just a digital shoebox if you don't bring the Rolodex spirit to it.

The most successful agents I’ve known throughout my career weren't necessarily the ones with the biggest databases; they were the ones who treated every digital entry with the same respect we used to give those tiny, handwritten cards.

So, as you prepare for the week ahead, take a moment to consider this:

If your CRM was a physical wheel of tiny, handwritten cards sitting on your desk right now, would you be more proud of the names inside it than you are of your impersonal database? Would you have taken the time to fill your Rolodex with 'leads' you've never actually spoken to, like the ones sitting in your database right now?

Until next time, try keeping it personal.

---

About the Author: I am a retired real estate professional with a career spanning 45 years. Throughout decades of market changes, I remained dedicated to the idea that real estate is about more than square footage—it’s about the human experience. Today, I write about the lessons learned from a lifetime of helping people find the place that truly feels like home, hoping that sharing these insights will help the next generation of agents better serve their clients and find fulfillment in their own careers.

(C) 2026 Jeff Sorg